TSC Strategic Priorities Meeting

TSC Strategic Priorities Meeting

Date

Jun 11, 2025 Jul 9, 2025 Aug 6, 2025

Disclosures

Participants

Voters | Quorum Required - 16 Name Affiliation Attended 6/11/2025 Attended 7/9/2025 Attended 8/6/2025 Austin (Jianlin) Gao Tencent Avi Timor Google X X Charlie Su Andes X X X David Brash Rivos Inc. X X X David Chen Stream Computing X X David Weaver Akeana X X Earl Killian - Unpriv IC Aril Inc. X X Erich Focht Openchip X Feiming Wang Sanechips/ZTE X Frans Sijstermans Nvidia Greg Favor - TSC Chair Ventana Micro Systems X X Guido Costa Souza Brazilian Ministry of Science Guohua Chen ESWIN X X Guy Lemieux - Com/Individ Elected Rep Individual X X X Haibin Shen Chengwei Captial Jian Zhang Beijing Institute of Open Source Chip X X X John Hengeveld Intel John Leidel - Technology HC Chair Tactical Computing Labs Kan Shi ICT CAS Ken Dockser - Strategic Elected Rep Tenstorrent X X X Krste Asanovic (SiFive) SiFive X X X Manu Gulati Qualcomm X Marcel Tromp Infineon X X Paul Holt Synopsys X Peter Chun Huawei Philipp Tomsich - TSC Vice-chair VRULL X X X Roger Espasa - Strategic Elected Rep Semidynamics Shi Yijun Sanechips/ZTE Shubu Mukherjee (Krste) SiFive X Siqi Zhao Alibaba Cloud X X Tom Zhao Phytium Wei Wu ISCAS X X Zhangzi Tan RIOS Non-Voters Name Affiliation Attended 6/11/2025 Attended 7/9/2025 Attended 8/6/2025 Andrew Dellow Qualcomm, Inc. X X X Andrew Waterman SiFive Anup Patel (Ventana Micro Systems) Ventana Micro Systems X Derek Hower Qualcomm, Inc. X X X Jiangang Duan Intel X Nambi JU Individual Ravi Sahita (Rivos Inc) Rivos Inc X X X Vedvyas Shanbhogue (Rivos Inc) Rivos Inc X X X Andrea Gallo (RISC-V International) RISC-V International X X X Bill Traynor (RISC-V International) RISC-V International X X Greg Sterling (RISC-V International) RISC-V International X X X Jeff Scheel (RISC-V International) RISC-V International X X X Rafael Sene (RISC-V International) RISC-V International X X X Austin Blackstone RISC-V International X

Agenda

TSC Strategic Gaps & Priorities Survey | Results Review and Discussion (Greg, Philipp, Andrea, Jeff, Rafael) (120 Minutes)

Presentations

Title

Presenter

File

Title

Presenter

File

1

 

 

 

2

 

 

 

Votes

None

Notes & Action Items

Audio links:

Detailed Notes

  • Next TSC Meeting: Platform SIG Needs Discussion (Andrea, Greg) (10 Minutes)

  • Background for meeting:

    • The goal is alignment within RISC-V

    • Participation is important

    • Resources are limited, thus let’s focus on items we can achieve within the next year

    • Collaboration makes us all more efficient and improves ROI

  • Premier Member Gaps Discussion

    • ISA

      • Virtualization for Real-time Processors noted as important to Automotive – BOSC, SiFive, Infineon, Synopsys, and others…

      • Enterprise/Datacenter/… gaps (#3)

        • Needs to be split in multiple pieces

        • Will focus on ISA items more than non-ISA

      • Vector item (#5) has new item of 56x56 carry-save-multi-add.

      • Speculation barriers being worked

      • Scalar (#7)

        • Most being worked starting with SIG, but also includes proposed Long Instruction TG

      • Sail (#8) wants Sail to move faster.

      • Long Instruction (#9) supported by Akeana as well.

      • Atomic Enqueue (#10) newly raised to mailing lists. Support being posted to list would be beneficial.

      • Vector Extension (#11)

        • crcfolder and vgmulxor instructions apply to storage. No need for Storage SIG at this time but will explore. Note: Carryless multiply helps here too.

        • fp4 not yet being looked at in FP SIG and Vector SIG

        • SFU item are motivated by AI activation functions, DSP, and other specialized applications

    • Non-ISA

      • Opensource IOMMU implementation (#1) available at University of Minho (Portugal): link | source

        • Discussion around reference implementations occurred: RISC-V remains focused on being a standards body

      • I/D Cache coherency (#2) started under J-ext TG (moved to SIG). FT extension being explored as starting point. More work expected. (Should move to ISA, 3-6)

      • HPE being worked (#4)

      • User mode timer and interrupts (#5) has been raised through HP IO SIG.

      • Documentation (#7) being shared with TSC, CSC, Doc SIG.

        • A lot of work to do around normative rule declaration. CSC, UDB SIG, Doc SIG building a proposal.

        • CSC and TSC will need to collaborate on the list to achieve successful results.

      • Side-channel (#10) also includes work on Speculation Barriers (new TG)

    • Profiles

      • Next RVA Profile (#1)

        • Next major 2+ years away (Profiles SIG)

        • Expect 1-2 minor releases pending

      • Security Profile (#2) discussion

        • Being built as “Security Model” specification

        • Might need a platform to build extensions + Security Model

      • RVA23+ challenges… (#3)

        • OSs tend to do WARL discovery making VM migration difficult

      • Debug/Trace and Interrupt Profiles (#6)

        • This is a request for inclusion of items in this area

        • Debug and interrupts are more of a Platform level consideration

        • These are key areas for Certification work as well

    • Platforms

      • #2 not solvable by RISC-V

      • #3 needs more refinement to clarify which areas of Automotive

      • Appears #4 not solvable by RISC-V as written, but may need more deep look

        • Discussion: are there areas of standardization that might not be purely RISC-V centric but still beneficial, e.g. AXI, AMBA.

        • Would recommend SOC Infrastructure HC lead this look

      • Certification Authority (#8) for software signing

        • Certificate to be provided to Secure Boot.

        • Andrea Gallo will help drive this considering the strategic and operational fronts.

      • #9 Platform Systems

        • Future new Industrial SIG Andrea Gallo and Philipp Tomsich and Manu Gulati (Deactivated)

    • Software

      • #1 AI extensions

        • Compilers already in Acceptance Criteria (Jira subtasks) so will apply to AI extensions

        • For AI/ML, need to ensure we cover up to frameworks/tools such as MLIR

        • Interlock with RISE, including TSC

      • #2

      • #7 Unified DB

        • Generated items need a process for review. Separating syntax and semantics as 2 parts may help. Finalize work on encodings (syntax).

        • Numerous items in the current process (opcodes db, Sail) are in use but clearly more efficiencies here.

        • UDB is working on how to help resolve duplications and provide greater efficiencies. But this will be complex to cover everything.

      • #8 appears to be in support of existing work

  • Strategic Member Gaps

    • ISA

      • #1, #2 have been covered by Premier gaps

      • #3 Custom Co-processors – defer until Krste and Greg are available

    • Profiles

      • #1 Automotive profiles

        • Already in progress in Automotive SIG and RVM TG.

      • #2 server virtualization

        • Covered by Server SOC work, RVA23, Server Platform

      • #3 Edge AI

        • Merge into other AI topics from Premier.

        • May need to to increase focus of AI beyond accelerators to Edge solutions and AIIoT. These solutions are mainly other architectures.

    • Platforms

    • Software

      • #1, #2 are downstream issues that are software ecosystem basis

        • Engagement in existing groups would help close images.

        • May to investigate where/which container images are built in the community v. enterprise Distro images

        • “Base images” may be key part

      • #3 of ISVs being slow

        • Not a technology/standards issue

        • Engagement by members will be required to solve

      • #4 Debuggers

        • May be a requirement for VTune. Unclear.

        • Enabling base tools. Becomes an ISV issue (like #3) when software becomes proprietary.

        • Ecosystem will continue to grow with hardware availability and solution growth

      • #5 Thermal and Power Management

        • RISC-V is standardizing around interfaces in BRS and ACPI

        • SBI implementing support

        • Awaiting HW support

      • #6 Mixed precision computing compiler support

        • Clarity required because ISA doesn’t support mixed precision

      • #7 OS support upstream

        • Need community education of partners to drive into community

      • #8 Boot standards

        • BRS for Servers but not really defined for embedded, but bespoke solution available in BRS

      • #9 AI

        • Batch with AI topics

      • #10 Vector optimizations

        • Merge with ISV item

        • Synergy with RISE

      • #11 Common Primitives for Matrix

        • Being driven by Toolchain SIG

  • Community Organization and Individual Gaps

    • ISA

      • #1 Neuromorphic extensions: has been raised before, but work never proceeded. If multiple companies who are interested, they can work with AI/ML SIG.

      • #2 Next gen crypto: PQC TG underway

      • #3 Power efficiency: RPMI interfaces recently ratified. May simply be micro-architecture but need more details.

      • #4 Standardized Crypto extension: covered by Crypto SIG

      • #5 Avoid fragmentation of extensions: role of ARC

      • #6 Vector and DSP: We don’t recognize Kinchit so need to understand this.

      • #7 Built in encryption commands: need specifics.

      • #8 Enhanced Bit-manip: Scalar Efficiency TG looking at this

      • #9 HW security integration: need specifics.

      • #10 Security/Crypto support: need specifics. HAC, PQC are occuring.

      • #11 Reconfig GPU design: unclear what is meant.

      • #12 Chains of parallel ops: AME, IME, VME being worked.

      • #13 General ISA security support: Too vague

      • #14 Vector, Matrix, Virtualization extensions: Appears to be covered.

    • Non-ISA

      • #1, #2: unclear

      • #3 Standard accelerator interfaces: CX TG

      • #4 Trusted Execution Environment: Supervisor domains, RISC-V Worlds

      • #5 Power: Again RPMI

      • #6: FPGA hardware gaps: unclear, maybe covered by CX TG

      • #7: Looking for SBI for micro-controllers.

    • Profiles

      • #1 Automotive: Automotive SIG and RVM Profile cover

      • #2 Compliance: CSC working

      • #3: Vague. We do mentorships, education, local events.

      • #4: Sounds like TEE.

      • #5, #6: need to understand who Kinchit.

      • #7: RVM.

      • #8: Profiles process documentation should address. Further speculation is difficult.

    • Platforms

      • #1: has to come from Members

      •  


Action items:

Virtualization for Real-time Processors → Priv IC and Automotive SIG
Datacenter SIG needs to announce restart (Rafael)
Point of Persistence → Priv IC
Rivos will bring 56x56 carry-save-multi-add to Vector SIG.
Sail update to Tech Ops with focus on backlog and PR acceptance (Jeff)
crcfolder and vgmulxor vector instructions (#11) → Vector SIG (Alibaba)
fp4 (#11) → Vector SIG and FP SIG (Alibaba)
SFU (#11) → FP SIG for gap analysis and further opportunity (Alibaba)
RVA23+ (Profiles #3) → Priv SW HC and BRS TG (Rivos)
Platform Automotive Security Model (#3) → Automotive SIG
SOC Interface exploration → SOC Infra HC
Decide how to share the results of the review with RISC-V Members.
Will need to ensure that interlocks with RISE includes AI topics and thus has visibility to/from TSC as well.
Finalize the plan for op-codes replacement by UDB and bring back to TSC.
Follow up on ISA #4 (Strategic) to see if Zve meets needs. (RISC-V Staff, Analog Devices)
Strategic Platform #2 (PXE boot, UEFI support) → Server Platform specification
Follow up on Strategic Platform #3 to find more details about request, lossy or low precision. (RISC-V Staff, E4)
Share Software requirements/priorities with RISE Interlock (Philipp)
Follow up on Strategic Software #6 to find more details about request, what does the ISA do that compilers don’t support. (RISC-V Staff, E4)
Send Microcontroller SBI request to SBI group (Guy)
Need to review authentication for next year’s collection (RISC-V Staff)

Adjournment

  • Motion to Adjourn Made By:

  • Seconded By:

  • Time Adjourned:


Standard_2.png

 

RISC-V International